Peter wants his son Jason to take out his friend's daughter Maggie Taylor while she's in town from New York. Jason is reluctant, since he remembers her as a geek. Scott remembers how Jason stood her up for the freshman prom back when they lived in New York. Jason bribes Murray into going out with Maggie in his place, but he changes his mind when she shows up and looks quite attractive. Meanwhile, Murray brings some puppies to the Lighthouse that are homeless after their animal shelter was damaged. Lisa, Alex and Traycee decide that a bachelor auction would be a good fund-raiser. Lisa wants Scott to be a part of it, but he's dubious. Traycee thinks Peter would fetch a good price at an auction. She and Lisa make a bet on which Collins could raise the most money. Jason and Maggie spend the morning together having fun, reminiscing about the crush she used to have on him. But Peter lets it slip to Maggie that Jason lied to her to get out of going to the prom years ago. Maggie acts like she