An Amish man, Isaiah Zook, travels to New York to search for his runaway daughter but is quickly overwhelmed by the city. Paterson happens upon the naive Isaiah and introduces him to Swift who quickly agrees to take his case. Swift discovers that Sarah, Isaiah's daughter, is living with a child pornography star, David, who owes his movie producer, Malcolm, a lot of money for drugs. David decides to trade Sarah in exchange for his freedom from Malcolm's thugs—but even David is unaware of Malcolm's plan to sell Sarah into white slavery.