Amanda and C.J. ""The Hottie and The Hard Body"" Look, but don't touch! Amanda and C.J. are attractive people who are not ""attracted"" to each other. Never fear, dull daters don't mean a dull date. Maybe Amanda and C.J. don't find love, but that's not the case for their Taildaters. Amy and Brett ""Sarcastic meets Clueless"" Brett is turned on by Amy's sarcastic wit. Unfortunately, she doesn't feel the same way, which is obvious to everyone except Brett. He is clueless until dinner when she makes it clear that she's not interested. Brett becomes bitter over a broken heart.