as

Self (archive footage)

as

Vesser

as

Self (archive footage)

as

Lear

as

(archive footage)

as

Self (archive footage) (uncredited)

as

Judge Henry G. Blake

as

Noah Tuttle

as

Grover Cleveland

as

Judge Bentley

as

Tom Todd

as

Hubert Willis

as

Self

as

Mayor Dick Williston

as

Emperor

as

O. Henry

as

John Day Griffith

as

Ben Cary

as

Cason Thomas

as

Nick Finn

as

Mr. Carson

as

Kris Kringle

as

'Pap' Finn

as

Dr. Joseph H. Walton

as

Ed Morgan

as

Reginald T. 'Rags' Barnaby

as

Blumenau

as

Old Man Finn

as

Mayor Thomas Russell

as

Fred Tupple

as

Mender McClure

as

Silas Lapham

as

Mayor Jonas Henderson

as

Silas Burton

as

Elmo

as

Gandy

as

William Oliver Gant

as

Sam Hawkins

as

Carl Smith

as

Truman Winters

as

Robert Baldwin

as

Johnny Reynolds, Sr.

as

Innkeeper

as

Ralp Burgess

as

Sam Partridge

as

Judge Calvin Cook

as

Joseph Foster

as

Arthur 'Red' Stanley

as

Dr. Paul Morgan

as

Henry Brown

as

John Plato Beck

as

Jack Guzzow

as

William Mallory

as

Hank Morgan

as

Capt. Thad Vail

as

Gill MacBean

as

Uncle Billy

as

Lt. Stevenson

as

Terence Alaysius O'Davern

as

Self

as

Mudgin

as

Warden Michael Howland

as

Ike Howard

as

Mr. Sydney

as

Mr. Thomas F. Sullivan

as

Ned Buntline

as

Willie Tulloch

as

Joseph Tumulty

as

Pat Garrett

as

Cpl. Jake Feingold

as

Sergeant Kelly

as

Septimus Podgers (segment 2)

as

John Halloway

as

Tommy Blue

as

Tiny

as

Father Antoine

as

"Monty" Montague

as

Dennis O'Brien

as

Self

as

Jonah Goodwin

as

Prof. Henry Todhunter

as

Doc Gibbs

as

Gene Gibbons

as

Driscoll

as

William Robinson

as

Peter Casey

as

Self

as

Doc Josiah Boone

as

Gerald O'Hara

as

Diz Moore

as

Clopin

as

Kid Dabb

as

Commissioner Blackton

as

Dan Painter

as

Henry Barnard

as

George Cooper

as

Hank Miller

as

Dr. Kersaint

as

District Attorney J.E. Curtis

as

William J. Grady

as

Jed Waterbury

as

Fergus Passmore

as

Phil Bane

as

Bertram Rogers

as

Theatre Play

as

Theatre Play

as

Screenplay

as

Theatre Play